Skip to main content

Hormone and Non-Hormonal Alternatives for Menopausal Treatment

The Perimenopause is that transitional time that can began as early as 10-15 years before actual menopause and continues until the post-menopause is well established. For many women, this will typically be around age early to mid 40’s until age 60 or older. At it’s best; one can have little to no symptoms and a very smooth progression. Many women will experience some very troubling symptoms including menstrual irregularity, hot flashes, night sweats, and anxiety/depression.
There are also potentially some changes related to inadequate vaginal estrogen, such as dryness, sensitivity and bladder weakness. In women who have surgical menopause related to the removal of the ovaries, these changes could be more abrupt. In women who have had a hysterectomy, the lack of periods can make the changes confusing. It is important to realize that everyone is different and especially in the premenopause or climacteric, hormonal swings occur throughout the day and variations may be noticed with no real predictable pattern. For these reasons, there are no exact hormone tests that offer meaningful information in most cases.
The best advice for everyone is to realize that each woman has a very individual situation that benefits greatly by good general health and prevention, diet, exercise and guidance from a knowledgeable healthcare expert. In addition, the situation is constantly progressing, and current options continue to evolve, new information is accumulated and people and attitudes also change. This means that effective help must be re-evaluated on an ongoing basis, at least annually and often much more frequently.
Nutritional and Herbal therapy have been used in place of and in addition to hormonal treatment for many years. The potential benefit of healthy and “natural” ingredients is attractive to many people. These treatments have generally not been as well studied and researched as products from the major pharmaceutical companies. There is however a growing body of evidence to suggest the safety and benefit of many non-prescription and herbal products, especially those from well-known and reputable companies. When the choice is to try these products, our advice is to start conservatively using small dosages and proceeding cautiously. A simple regimen or formula is probably safer than a complex mixture. There are several well-accepted herbs and supplements currently in the market and many different products. If initial success with these products is not adequate, we can offer additional advice and suggest additional steps to take.
“Natural hormone” replacement therapy suggests that the chemical makeup of the product is bio-identical or exactly the same as what the human body produces. Most pharmaceutical company products are actually derived or processed from natural sources. Premarin estrogen product, for example, is processed from the urine of pregnant mares. Many other estrogen products are processed by pharmaceutical companies from plant sources. There is a small industry that has been created by some pharmacists who produce a custom-made formula with a doctor’s prescription, using any of a variety of ingredients in any chosen dosage. The benefit here is that a custom product can be created for each individual patient and adjusted accordingly. This offers significantly more choice in designing a supplement for a particular purpose. The disadvantage is that a particular formula may not have any clinical research backing or testing and the patient and the physician must have trust in the pharmacist who is actually compounding the product in their store or lab. There may be much more variation in one batch to the next and certainly from one pharmacy to the next.
Pharmaceutical company factory-made products are known for their consistency and standardization although there is not as much variety and choice in ingredients. Certainly patients can consider both options and may actually find success with compounded formulas if traditional store-bought products are not effective or cause side effects. It is important to know that these hormones have many of the same potential risks as products made by the pharmaceutical companies and the benefits are not as well documented.
A variety of dosage forms can be developed by these specialized pharmacists to meet the specific needs of each woman. Options include: 1) Transdermal or through the skin dosage forms such as gels, troches, or suppositories, 2) Capsules containing micronized particles for improved oral absorption, 3) Unique ingredients and “lesser” hormones which are not always available in commercial products and may be better suited to an individual woman’s specific needs.
We can currently recommend several pharmacies for compounded hormones and products, 1) Family Pharmacy, 3644 Webber Street, Sarasota, Florida 34232 (941) 923-7558. 2) Kinnards on Siesta Drive, and 3) several mail order pharmacies.

Weaning off or stopping hormone therapy
If the plan involves going off or stopping hormones, then typically this should be a gradual process over a period of time. My most common recommendation is as follows:
1. reduce estrogen daily dosage to next lower level every 2-4 weeks until the lowest dosage is reached
2. if symptoms of lower estrogen become significant, then maintain current dosage for several weeks and, if necessary, increase to next highest dosage for 2-4 weeks
3. once the lowest dosage is reached, then alternate days on treatment and off treatment
4. for patch wearers, the last patch can be followed by no treatment
5. while weaning or stopping, use non-hormonal alternatives if possible…these include vitamin E and soy protein foods and, if necessary, herbal supplements such as Promensil, or Remifemin
6. discuss other options for bone health, cardiovascular health and non-estrogen hormones such as progesterone and androgens for a customized plan of hormone health

Various options of hormone support treatment
The Classic Step-wise Approach to any treatment involves trying the simplest and often safest therapy before moving to stronger and often a more intensive strategy. Still, some patients may opt for an aggressive strategy if symptoms are creating major disruptions. For most patients, a carefully chosen prescription hormone supplement used over a relative short term has a high benefit and low risk profile. Once severe symptoms have been stabilized over a period of time, patients may want to try a lower dosage program or slowly stop prescription hormones completely. Some research studies have suggested higher risks for certain types of cancers and cardiovascular events in certain patient groups. Whether there really are any newly identified increased risks or not, caution should be exercised with the use of any prescription (and non-prescription) medication or products.
First Step for Hormonal Support:
1) Increase supplemental Vitamin E to 800-1000 units daily. This is generally safe and effective (Check blood pressure periodically). There are generally believed to be vitamin E benefits for cardiovascular and breast problems as well.
2) Increase nutritional Soy-based foods and even consider Soy protein supplements if absolutely necessary (see food source list under phytohormones).
Second step:
Choose a scientifically, research-backed, Vitamin/Nutritional and Herbal combination:
1) Women’s Isoguard by Clinician’s Choice ordered by mail or fax from Virginia.
We have an order form and a toll-free number.
2) Promensil 500 mg. daily…. over the counter.
3) Remifemin herbal combination…over the counter.
4) Estroven herbal combination…over the counter.
4) The key is comparing ingredients and trusting a manufacturer for quality and consistency. Key ingredients are Black Cohosh, Dong Quai, Isoflavinoids and Evening Primrose Oil.

**Also consider natural progesterone (like Progest Cream – available at health food stores, etc.) This is available non-prescription and there are stronger prescription strengths that can be ordered. Progesterone is derived from Wild Yam Root typically at a dosage of about 150 mg.
Third Step:
Consultation regarding compounded or prescription formulary hormone replacement products. Some patients should consider hormone replacement in light of specific medical benefits that may outweigh potential risks. These conditions may include severe menopausal symptoms, osteoporosis, significant sexual dysfunction, Alzheimer’s family history, or vaginal and bladder issues. Women with a history of breast cancer, uterine cancer or significant risks for any female cancer or blood clots, should generally not use estrogen products (at least not on an ongoing basis). Natural progesterone products are generally safe for these patients.

On hormone treatment for menopause/perimenopause, our office policy is as follows: We believe that recent studies and the media have exaggerated the risks of hormone therapy. The pharmaceutical companies and overzealous doctors have perhaps exaggerated the benefits of hormones. The real facts are that for some women, hormone therapy is essential for quality of life, and for other women, they are dangerous and should be avoided. For the majority of women, an individualized approach should be taken with a careful analysis of that patient’s needs, risks and experience.

Also, this should be reanalyzed regularly (yearly) because options, needs, situations and alternatives change too. Hormones carry a potential risk of accelerating breast cancer growth, increasing thromboembolic risks, gall bladder risks and may increase EXISTING cardiovascular disease (synthetic progestins, especially Provera are believed by many to be the culprit in lipid change and CVD risk). Hormones definitely help bone strength, bladder and vaginal tissues and probably healthy vascular systems. Most researchers believe there is a benefit in cognitive (brain) function.

Author
Swor Women's Care

You Might Also Enjoy...

Advanced Gyn Laparoscopy for Endometriosis

One of our primary specialties is Advanced Laparoscopic Surgery for endometriosis. We have treated over 5000 women with pelvic pain, painful periods, infertility or other issues related to endometriosis using the most advanced techniques.

Gyn Surgery Experts

Swor Women’s Care is the region’s most experienced advanced gynecology surgery practice. Since 1985, we have successfully completed more than 10,000 advanced gynecologic surgery procedures.